One of the resons for the Treaty of Waitangi was

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Question restatement: One of the resons for the Treaty of Waitangi was

Option provided: a. Bring unruly British subjects under control

Analysis of the option:
- Opening perspective: The claim suggests the treaty’s purpose included disciplining or controlling British subjects within New Zealand. This framing centers the treaty on managing settlers’ behavior rather than establishing a formal legal framework for governance between Maori and the Crown.
- Historical context: The Treaty of Waitangi (1840) was primarily drafted to create a legal basis for British governance in New Zealand, to protect Maori land rights and chiefs (rangatira), and to establish a framework for orderly settlement and law enforcement. It aimed to prevent conflict between settlers and Maori by defining sovereignty (kāwanatanga) and governance, while recognizing Maori authority in certain domains. The idea of “bringing unruly British subjects under control” does not align with the documented core purposes of the treaty; it places emphasis on disciplining settlers rather than outlining state–indigenous relations or legal protections.
- Implication of accuracy: If interpreted literally, this option implies the treaty existed to manage colonists, which would be historically inaccurate as a primary motivation. The treaty’s text and historians generally frame its goals around governance, protection of property, and establishing a legal order in a colonial context, not policing Britain’s own people.
- Potential misconception: The wording could reflect a simplistic or biased view that places responsibility on the Crown for disciplining settlers rather than recognizing the treaty’s broader aims to create a workable colonial framework and address Maori rights and sovereignty concerns.
- What would strengthen the option if it were accurate: If the statement were reframed to say something like “to establish a formal framework for governing relationships between the Crown, settlers, and Maori, and to bring order to the colonization process,” it would be closer to accepted historical accounts.

Given only this option, the reasoning suggests it is an incomplete and misleadingly narrow depiction of the treaty’s aims. It misses the core elements of establishing governance, protecting Maori rights, and setting up legal order between diverse groups. The broader historical purpose is not captured by the idea of controlling British subjects alone.

LINC101_S1 Quiz 5

One of the resons for the Treaty of Waitangi was

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

Who were the main signatories of the Treaty of Waitangi?

Who were the main signatories of the Treaty of Waitangi?

What was signed in 1840?1840 年签署了什么？

In the English version of the Treaty of Waitangi, which of the following is NOT one of the three articles?在英文版的《怀唐伊条约》中，以下哪一项不是三篇文章中的一篇？

Which of the following is NOT a reason for Treaty settlements

In the English version of the Treaty of Waitangi, which of the following is NOT one of the three articles