In the market for a common property resource, the unregulated market outcome will occur at what point?

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Question restatement: In the market for a common property resource, the unregulated market outcome will occur at what point?

Given answer: When profits per user fall to zero.

Analysis of the concept: In an open-access or common-property situation, there are no well-defined property rights or price signals to limit use. Each user gains the marginal private benefit from additional unit of the resource, while the cost is borne by all users collectively. Since there is no mechanism to charge for use or to enforce quantity limits, individuals continue to extract more of the resource as long as they still gain any positive private profit from an extra unit. As long as the marginal user’s revenue exceeds their marginal cost, they have an incentive to keep taking more, driving use up until the additional user’s profit from that last unit drops to zero. At that point, the last unit’s marginal private benefit just covers the marginal private cost, so no one has an incentive to extract one more unit.

Why this is the case in plain terms: Without property rights or pricing, there’s no exclusive ownership to prevent overuse. Each user acts to maximize personal gain, ignoring the external costs imposed on others. This leads to excessive exploitation of the resource until the individual’s net gain per extra unit is zero.

Why this option is plausible given the context: The criterion of zero profit per user marks the threshold where an additional user would not find it profitable to extract more, signaling overuse and a potential collapse of the resource if extraction continues. It aligns with standard open-access/resource economics intuition that unregulated access tends to maximize aggregate use until marginal profit per user is zero.

What makes other possible interpretations unlikely here (in a typical exam on common-p-property markets): If the question offered alternatives such as “at the efficient allocation” or “until marginal social benefit equals marginal social cost,” those would be incorrect because the unregulated outcome fails to internalize externalities and does not achieve efficiency. If an option suggested “profits never fall to zero” or “use is unlimited,” these would ignore the diminishing marginal returns and the shared costs, making them inconsistent with open-access dynamics. If it claimed zero price or no profits regardless of use, that would misstate the incentive structure under open access, where users seek positive profits until constraints bind.

ECON 2010-090 Summer 2025 Module 9 Quiz Due June 19th

In the market for a common property resource, the unregulated market outcome will occur at what point?

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

A market situation where all participants have an incentive to exploit a resource yet no one can limit anyone else's access to that resource, resulting in over-exploitation, can be described as a(n) __________.

Which of the following resources is LEAST likely to suffer from a tragedy of the commons?

A market situation where all participants have an incentive to exploit a resource yet no one can limit anyone else's access to that resource, resulting in over-exploitation, can be described as a(n) __________.

The __________ is the idea that the pursuit of self-interest with no consideration for societal interests leads to disaster.

Which of the following is NOT a type of solution to the 'tragedy of the commons'?

The overuse of a common resource relative to its economically efficient use is called

更多留学生实用工具

考试浏览器助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单