Common resources are

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Question: Common resources are

Option context: The answer options are not provided in the dataset, but the given answer label is 'b. overused.' which suggests a debate about whether common resources tend to be overused.

Analysis of the concept in general:
- Common resources typically refer to common-pool resources: items that are rivalrous (one person’s use reduces availability for others) but non-excludable (no easy way to prevent anyone from using them). This combination often leads to overuse unless management mechanisms exist.
- The classical concern here is the tragedy of the commons: without proper incentives, supervision, or rules, individuals overexploit the resource because the costs of overuse are borne by the group but the benefits accrue to the individual.

Evaluating the idea that common resources are overused:
- Strength of the claim: It is commonly taught in environmental economics and resource management that common-pool resources are prone to overuse when no regulation exists. This supports the statement that they can be overused under typical, unmanaged conditions.
- Context sensitivity: The extent of overuse depends on governance, property rights, monitoring, enforcement, and community norms. In well-managed common resources, overuse can be mitigated or prevented.
- Potential alternative characterization: Some contexts may experience underuse or inefficient use due to barriers to access, weak enforcement, or underinvestment, especially in poorly defined property rights or lack of knowledge about sustainable yields. Therefore, overuse is not an automatic or unconditional outcome in every situation.

Common misconceptions to watch for:
- Confusing public goods with common-pool resources: Public (non-rival) goods are not typically subject to overuse in the same way; the problem with public goods is under-provision, not overuse.
- Assuming excludability: If a resource is easily excludable, overuse pressure may be reduced; the non-excludability of common resources is a key driver of overuse risk.

Why the statement 'overused' can be correct in many real-world cases:
- Without rules, individuals acting in self-interest can deplete the resource since the cost of depletion is distributed among all users while the benefit of exploitation goes to the exploiter.
- Historical examples (fishing grounds, grazing land, groundwater) frequently illustrate overuse when collective management is weak or absent.

Why the statement can be incomplete or contested:
- If there is effective governance, clear property rights, or community-managed rules, common resources can be maintained sustainably, reducing or eliminating overuse.
- Some common resources may even experience underuse if access is too restricted or if the community undervalues the long-term benefits due to short-term incentives.

Bottom line:
- The claim that common resources are overused reflects a common theoretical and empirical pattern under unmanaged conditions; however, the actual outcome depends critically on governance, rights, and incentives. If the question's intended answer is 'overused,' it aligns with the standard tragedy-of-the-commons intuition in the absence of constraints, but it is essential to recognize that proper management can alter this outcome and prevent overuse.

MCD2020 - T1 - 2025 Homework Quiz 5 - Reopened

Common resources are

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

A market situation where all participants have an incentive to exploit a resource yet no one can limit anyone else's access to that resource, resulting in over-exploitation, can be described as a(n) __________.

Which of the following resources is LEAST likely to suffer from a tragedy of the commons?

A market situation where all participants have an incentive to exploit a resource yet no one can limit anyone else's access to that resource, resulting in over-exploitation, can be described as a(n) __________.

The __________ is the idea that the pursuit of self-interest with no consideration for societal interests leads to disaster.

Which of the following is NOT a type of solution to the 'tragedy of the commons'?

The overuse of a common resource relative to its economically efficient use is called

更多留学生实用工具

考试浏览器助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单