Q6 V3Consider the following TLC plate of compounds X, Y and Z developed using a suitable mobile phase on a polar stationary phase. Which of the following is correct?

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Question restatement: The TLC plate shows three components X, Y and Z developed on a polar stationary phase with a suitable mobile phase. We must choose which statement is correct about their relative polarity and Rf values.

Option a: 'Z is more polar than X and has a higher Rf value than X.' On a polar stationary phase, more polar compounds interact more strongly with the stationary phase, which lowers their Rf (they travel less). If Z were more polar than X, Z would typically have a lower Rf, not a higher one. Additionally, claiming Z has a higher Rf than X contradicts the expected trend for a polar stationary phase. Therefore this statement is inconsistent with the usual TLC polarity behavior and is unlikely to be correct.

Option b: 'X is the most polar component and has an Rf value of 0.80.' If X were the most polar, it would interact most strongly with the stationary phase and would move the least, giving a relatively low Rf. An Rf of 0.80 suggests considerable movement up the plate, which would be unusual for the most polar compound on a polar stationary phase. This makes the statement questionable and likely incorrect.

Option c: 'Z is more polar than Y and has a higher Rf value than Y.' If Z were more polar than Y, Z should have a stronger interaction with the stationary phase and thus a lower Rf than Y. Claiming that Z has a higher Rf than Y contradicts the premise that Z is more polar. Therefore this option is inconsistent with the polarity–Rf relationship on a polar stationary phase and is not correct.

Option d: 'Y is the least polar component and has an Rf value of 0.78.' This aligns with the general principle: on a polar stationary phase, the least polar compound interacts least with the stationary phase and travels farther with the mobile phase, yielding a higher Rf. An Rf of 0.78 is a plausible value for a component that travels well up the plate but not to the solvent front, and labeling Y as the least polar fits the reported trend. This option is consistent with standard TLC behavior and matches the provided answer key.

Summary of reasoning: In TLC on a polar stationary phase, polarity inversely affects mobility: more polar compounds have lower Rf due to stronger interaction with the stationary phase, while less polar compounds move farther and have higher Rf values. Applying this to the options, only statement d coherently matches the expected polarity–Rf relationship and the given hint that Y is least polar with a relatively high Rf (0.78).

MUF0042 Chemistry Unit 2 - Semester 2, 2025

Q6 V3Consider the following TLC plate of compounds X, Y and Z developed using a suitable mobile phase on a polar stationary phase. Which of the following is correct?

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

Samples of three amino acids A, B and C, were spotted on the base line of a TLC plate. The chromatogram produced using a particular solvent is shown below: Amino acids Rf values alanine 0.56 isoleucine 0.79 taurine 0.34 Use the TLC plate and Rf values given to identify amino acid A.

A student runs a TLC of a red pigment using a silica plate an ethyl acetate as the solvent. The red pigment was found to move 2.3 cm and the solvent front was measured to be 5.5 cm. What is the Rf of the red pigment?

What is the name of the line labelled Y in the following chromatogram?

What is the name of the line labelled X in the following chromatogram?

更多留学生实用工具

考试浏览器助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单