True or False:

Informal social control is more effective than formal control in regulating behavior.

Question

True or False:

Informal social control is more effective than formal control in regulating behavior.

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Question restatement: True or False — Informal social control is more effective than formal control in regulating behavior.

Option 1: True. This claim posits that informal social control (norms, expectations, peer pressure, reputation, praise or gossip) tends to regulate behavior more effectively than formal mechanisms (laws, rules, sanctions imposed by authorities). Proponents argue that informal control operates continuously, is pervasive in daily life, and often motivates people to conform without formal enforcement. It leverages social sanctions such as approval or ostracism, which can create strong internalized norms and long-lasting behavioral habits. It can be particularly powerful in communities or organizations where trust, shared values, and established routines guide how people behave, and where formal oversight is less visible or less trusted. However, this view has limits: informal control may be slower to change, less effective with strangers or high-stakes violations, and can be inconsistent or biased because it depends on who holds social influence. In some situations, informal control may fail to deter harmful behavior when social norms are weak, conflicting, or when individuals can recede behind anonymity or sanction-free environments.

Option 2: False. This statement claims that informal control is not necessarily more effective, implying formal control can be equally or more effective in regulating behavior in many contexts. Formal controls provide clear, codified expectations and consistently applied consequences, which can be crucial for ensuring compliance in large organizations, legal systems, or situations requiring uniform standards. They can deter behavior through credible sanctions, enable accountability across diverse populations, and be essential when social norms are insufficient to prevent harm or illegality. Yet, formal controls may be resented, understood as coercive, or circumvented through corruption or loopholes. Moreover, formal mechanisms can be slower to adapt to new circumstances and may fail if not properly implemented or perceived as illegitimate. Therefore, asserting that informal control is always more effective ignores the nuanced interplay between informal and formal processes, depending on context, culture, stakes, and the individuals involved.

Synthesis: The effectiveness of informal versus formal control is not an absolute rule; it varies by situation. In many everyday settings, informal control plays a dominant role in guiding ordinary conduct, but formal control remains crucial for ensuring compliance with universal standards, protecting against serious harms, and coordinating behavior across large groups or institutions. The best understanding recognizes that both forms of control interact and complement each other rather than one universally surpassing the other.

Introduction to Sociology Exam #1

True or False: Informal social control is more effective than formal control in regulating behavior.

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

Social control can be described as:

Which is an example of formal social control?

Cultural sanctions can also be viewed as ways that society:

In Émile Durkheim's view,

Janet is visiting her childhood friend in the Hamptons. Janet wears ripped jeans and Chuck Taylors to an infamous “White” party. The majority of party-goers refuse to socialize with her. Janet is experiencing a form of ____.

Religious beliefs are an important element of social control because they

Michel Foucault examined the emergence of the modern penal system, from physical punishment of the body to attempting to correct or reform bad habits. According to your textbook, this shift represents the transformation in

A The main idea of control theory is that most people have strong desires to be deviant, but two systems work against their motivation to deviate. These two systems are termed ________.

更多留学生实用工具

考试浏览器助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单