Which of the following uses the pronoun "that/who" correctly?

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

The question asks which option uses the pronoun 'that' or 'who' correctly when referring to a person.
Option 1: The speech pathologist worked with a stroke patient who she knew was suffering from aphasia. This uses 'who' to refer to the patient, a person, which is appropriate. In standard English, 'who' is the preferred relative pronoun for people, especially in clauses that function as the subject of a verb (in this case, 'was suffering'). The embedded idea 'she knew' remains correctly connected to the relative clause.
Option 2: The speech pathologist worked with a stroke patient that she knew was suffering from aphasia. Here, 'that' is used to refer to a person. While 'that' can be used for things and sometimes for people in restrictive clauses, the traditional rule in formal grammar reserves 'who' (or sometimes 'whom' in object position) for people. Using 'that' with a person is generally considered less appropriate or more informal, and this makes the sentence sound off to careful readers.
A few additional clarifications:
- If the sentence were written as 'The speech pathologist worked with a stroke patient who she knew was suffering from aphasia,' the structure is cleaner and adheres to the conventional choice of 'who' for people in a relative clause.
- 'That' is perfectly fine when the antecedent is a non-human noun (e.g., 'the book that she read'), but for a human antecedent, 'who' is the safer and more widely accepted option.
- The placement of 'she knew' inside the relative clause also matters for readability; keeping the clause clear helps prevent misreading of who is performing the action.
In summary, Option 1 correctly uses the pronoun 'who' for a person, whereas Option 2 misuses 'that' in reference to a person, making it the incorrect choice.

Which of the following uses the pronoun "that/who" correctly?

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

China, (_____) economy has been transformed by technological innovation, is quickly gaining a competitive advantage over other countries.

位置27的问题 The student ____ finishes first wins a prize. thatwhichwho

Which of these is not a correct sentence?

China, (_____) economy has been transformed by technological innovation, is quickly gaining a competitive advantage over other countries.

In the sentence ‘Safe drinking water is a challenge for people that live in the developing world ’, that could be replaced with which.

China, (_____) economy has been transformed by technological innovation, is quickly gaining a competitive advantage over other countries.

In the sentence ‘Safe drinking water is a challenge for people that live in the developing world ’, that could be replaced with which.

Can the word "who" in the sentence below be replaced by the word "that"? Eating well and exercising is important for students who are stressed.

更多留学生实用工具

考试浏览器助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单