In the sentence ‘Safe drinking water is a challenge for people that live in the developing world ’, that could be replaced with which.

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

The task presents the sentence: “Safe drinking water is a challenge for people that live in the developing world ”, that could be replaced with which. The options are:
Option 1: True
Option 2: False

Option 1 analysis (True): This would claim that the relative pronoun “that” in the clause “people that live in the developing world” can be swapped with “which” without changing the grammatical status or meaning. In English, “which” is typically used for nonrestrictive (nonessential) clauses and is usually preceded by a comma. Here, the clause “that live in the developing world” is restrictive because it specifies which people are being talked about. Therefore, saying it could be replaced with “which” would be misleading, as it would either require adding a comma and shifting punctuation or would alter the style of the clause. This reasoning makes the statement false in standard grammar practice.

Option 2 analysis (False): The more accurate claim is that substituting “that” with “which” is not appropriate in this sentence as written, because the clause identifies a specific group of people. In strict terms, for restrictive clauses describing essential information about the noun, “that” or “who” would be conventional, while “which” would be reserved for nonrestrictive, nonessential clauses and typically paired with a comma. Since the sentence uses a restrictive sense (people who live in the developing world), replacing with “which” would be incorrect or would require re-punctuation to reflect a nonrestrictive usage. This makes the statement that it could be replaced with “which” incorrect, aligning with the given answer which marks False as the correct choice.

Additional nuance: If one rewrites with “who” (e.g., “people who live in the developing world”), that would be a common and arguably clearer alternative, but the question centers on replacing with “which.” Because the standard use of “which” in nonrestrictive clauses would demand a comma and a different meaning, the replacement is not appropriate in the original restrictive context. Thus, the claim in Option 1 is flawed, and Option 2 correctly identifies the issue.

In summary, the statement in Option 1 asserts a permissible replacement that conflicts with typical restrictive-clause usage, while Option 2 correctly flags the inappropriateness of replacing with “which” in this sentence as written.

ME Mod4 Intake 2A - 14 Apr 2025 - 4 Jul 2025 Activity 4.5B - Reduced Relative Clauses Review Quiz

In the sentence ‘Safe drinking water is a challenge for people that live in the developing world ’, that could be replaced with which.

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

China, (_____) economy has been transformed by technological innovation, is quickly gaining a competitive advantage over other countries.

位置27的问题 The student ____ finishes first wins a prize. thatwhichwho

Which of the following uses the pronoun "that/who" correctly?

Which of these is not a correct sentence?

China, (_____) economy has been transformed by technological innovation, is quickly gaining a competitive advantage over other countries.

In the sentence ‘Safe drinking water is a challenge for people that live in the developing world ’, that could be replaced with which.

China, (_____) economy has been transformed by technological innovation, is quickly gaining a competitive advantage over other countries.

Can the word "who" in the sentence below be replaced by the word "that"? Eating well and exercising is important for students who are stressed.

更多留学生实用工具

考试浏览器助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单