Fossil records suggest that appendage regeneration such as tail and limb regeneration were an ancient trait present at the base of the tetrapod (limbed vertebrate) lineage

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Question restatement: The prompt asks whether fossil records indicate that appendage regeneration (such as tail and limb regeneration) was an ancient trait present at the base of the tetrapod (limbed vertebrate) lineage.
Option 1: True. Arguments that could support this claim include the idea that regenerative abilities seen in some modern amphibians (e.g., salamanders that can regenerate limbs and tails) might reflect an ancestral capability within tetrapods. If regeneration were widespread in early tetrapods, one might expect some fossil or comparative phylogenetic signals suggesting deep ancestry. However, it is important to note that soft-tissue regeneration is not typically preserved in the fossil record, so direct fossil evidence would be extremely rare or nonexistent. Paleontologists often rely on comparative developmental biology and extant species to infer ancestral traits, but such inferences about ancient regenerative capacity remain tentative and indirect. So, while there is a plausible argument that regeneration could trace back to early tetrapods, the fossil record itself provides little to no direct evidence for this trait, making the claim contentious rather than definitively supported.
Option 2: False. The primary challenge to the statement is that fossil preservation of soft tissues and healing processes is exceedingly unlikely; most fossils capture bones and hard structures, not regenerative events or capabilities. Therefore, asserting that the fossil record demonstrates an ancient regenerative trait at the base of tetrapods overstates what the evidence can show. Without direct soft-tissue preservation or clear skeletal correlates indicating a regenerative program, it is not scientifically sound to claim an ancient, fixed trait for regeneration at the base of the tetrapod lineage. Additionally, modern diversity in regenerative capacity among tetrapods suggests that if regeneration had been present ancestrally, lineages may have subsequently lost or modified it, complicating any straightforward inference from fossils alone. 
Between these two options, the argument hinges on the strength and nature of the available evidence: direct fossil evidence for regeneration is lacking, so the safer, more evidence-based stance is that fossil records do not show this trait as an unequivocal ancient baseline characteristic. Nonetheless, contemporary biology leaves room for the possibility that ancestral tetrapods possessed broader regenerative potential than seen in most descendants, which would not be directly visible in fossils.
Note: A careful appraisal emphasizes the limitations of the fossil record for soft-tissue phenomena and relies on comparative biology to assess ancestral traits.

Fossil records suggest that appendage regeneration such as tail and limb regeneration were an ancient trait present at the base of the tetrapod (limbed vertebrate) lineage

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

Match the animal regeneration examples with the regeneration strategy used to regrow the structure: 1: Hydra whole body regeneration 2: Human liver regeneration 3: Axon regeneration 4: Planaria regeneration 5: Salamander limb regeneration

Match the people with their discoveries: 1: Thomas Hunt Morgan 2: Abraham Trembley 3: Lazzarro Spallanzanni

Irradiating the anterior half of the planaria and amputating the head will regenerate because cells from a distant posterior region can migrate to the amputation plane

Upon irradiating the entire planaria how many cells are needed in a graft in order to regenerate all the cells in the animal?

The observation of animal regeneration in the 1700's challenged the idea of preformationism because of which of the following arguments?

Question at position 7 Forests more suited to climate change can only be prepared where Question Blank 1 of 1[input] occurs.

In a consumer society, many adults channel creativity into buying things

Economic stress and unpredictable times have resulted in a booming industry for self-help products

更多留学生实用工具

考试浏览器助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单