Question at position 20 You fit a polynomial regression model using Diastolic Blood Pressure regressed on Age. To find the best polynomial model, you tried polynomial with degree from 2 to 5. Based on the R output below, which of the following statements is correct? . The best model is polynomial with degree 5 because it has the highest R-square and lowest residual standard error. Without further information, no conclusion can be made about which model is the best. The best model is polynomial with degree 2 because it has the largest F statistic thus the smallest p-value for overall model significance. The best model is polynomial with degree 4 because the polynomial with degree 5 has a non-significant term for degree 5. None of them is correct!Clear my selection

Question

Question at position 20 You fit a polynomial regression model using Diastolic Blood Pressure regressed on Age. To find the best polynomial model, you tried polynomial with degree from 2 to 5. Based on the R output below, which of the following statements is correct? .  The best model is polynomial with degree 5 because it has the highest R-square and lowest residual standard error. Without further information, no conclusion can be made about which model is the best. The best model is polynomial with degree 2 because it has the largest F statistic thus the smallest p-value for overall model significance. The best model is polynomial with degree 4 because the polynomial with degree 5 has a non-significant term for degree 5. None of them is correct!Clear my selection

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Let me walk through each option and weigh what the R output tells us about model adequacy across polynomial degrees.
Option 1: The best model is polynomial with degree 5 because it has the highest R-square and lowest residual standard error.
In the output, while the degree-5 model does show a very small residual standard error and a sizable R-squared, those metrics alone can be misleading for model selection when higher-degree terms may be non-significant or cause overfitting. The presence of a non-significant term among the degree-5 coefficients would argue against simply picking degree 5 based on R-squared alone, because R-squared tends to increase (or at least not decrease) with model complexity even if the added terms do not meaningfully improve the fit. Therefore, this criterion (highest R-squared and lowest residual SE) is not sufficient by itself to claim degree 5 is best, especially if terms are not significant.
Option 2: Without further information, no conclusion can be made about which model is the best.
The output includes detailed coefficient tables, standard errors, t-values, and p-values for each polynomial degree (2 through 5), along with residual standard error and F-statistics. While one should be cautious, the presence of significant F-tests and per-term significance across degrees provides information. Saying “no conclusion” ignores the available evidence about term significance (particularly the non-significant degree-5 term). Hence this statement is overly conservative given the displayed results.
Option 3: The best model is polynomial with degree 2 because it has the largest F statistic thus the smallest p-value for overall model significance.
From the R output, the degree-2 model has an F-statistic of 251.7 with p-value extremely small, but we should compare with degree-3, degree-4, and degree-5 models. The degree-3 model has a larger F-statistic (169.4) and a highly significant overall p-value, but the degree-4 and degree-5 models show even larger F-statistics and still highly significant p-values. The observation that degree-2 has the largest F-statistic among all is false — degree-4 and degree-5 show larger F-statistics and thus stronger overall model significance. Therefore this statement misidentifies which degree maximizes the overall model significance.
Option 4: The best model is polynomial with degree 4 because the polynomial with degree 5 has a non-significant term for degree 5.
This matches the pattern in the output: the degree-5 model includes a term poly(Age, degree = 5)5 with a t-value around -1.43 and p-value about 0.153, which is non-significant at conventional levels. The degree-4 model has all its terms significant (or at least the degree-4 terms show strong significance) and an F-test with a very small p-value (< 2.2e-16) and a substantial R-squared. The non-significance of the extra degree-5 term suggests that the additional complexity of degree 5 does not meaningfully improve the model and may be overfitting, so stopping at degree 4 is reasonable. This aligns with standard model-diagnostic reasoning where a non-significant higher-degree term argues for a simpler model.
Option 5: None of them is correct!
Given the presence of a non-significant degree-5 term and the improved parsimony and maintained significance with degree 4, this option would be incorrect because there is a justifiable best model among the presented choices, namely the degree-4 model for the reasons described in option 4.

In summary, evaluating the progression from degree 2 to degree 5 shows that while higher degrees can inflate fit metrics, a non-significant term in the highest-degree model (degree 5) indicates that the extra complexity is not warranted. The degree-4 model provides a good balance of explanatory power and parsimony, and the evidence from the output supports selecting degree 4 over degree 5. The other options either rely on incomplete criteria, misinterpret the direction of model significance, or ignore the non-significant term issue in the degree-5 model.

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

The most common functional form that is nonlinear in the variables is the _______ form.

When fitting a linear model with polynomial basis functions, which of the following has no impact on the model complexity?

In the context of polynomial regression models, which of the following statements are true about the coefficient of determination (R²)? Select all that apply.

If we square a feature and then apply a linear regression, it's equivalent to building a model such as.

Now, add stotal2 to the equation you estimated in Question 14. Does a quadratic in the test score variable stotal seem necessary?

Consider m-th order polynomial regression. Which of the the following statements are true? [Select ALL that apply.]

In a consumer society, many adults channel creativity into buying things

Economic stress and unpredictable times have resulted in a booming industry for self-help products

更多留学生实用工具

考试浏览器助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单