What is the key issue in the case of Ferguson v FCT?

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Question: What is the key issue in the case of Ferguson v FCT?
Select one:
	a. A single venture can satisfy ‘carrying on a business’ in certain circumstances
	b. Mutuality of rights, and not the words used, will determine whether a partnership exists
	c. A business is carried on in a ‘business-like manner’
	d. To be carrying on a business in common, the parties must be engaged in the same business.

Option a: This statement reflects the nuanced principle from Ferguson v FCT, where courts have recognized that carrying on a business for tax purposes can be satisfied by a single venture under specific conditions. It emphasizes that the activity may constitute carrying on a business even if executed through one project or undertaking, rather than requiring multiple ventures. This aligns with the case’s exploration of how “carrying on a business” can be established beyond the most obvious or traditional forms, focusing on the substance of the activity rather than the label.

Option b: This option asserts that mutuality of rights, not the words used, determines partnership existence. While the presence of mutual rights can be relevant in partnership analysis, Ferguson v FCT does not reduce the test to mere mutuality alone; it also considers the actual carrying on of a business, the nature of the venture, and the arrangement. Therefore, this option oversimplifies the test and misstates the focus of the case.

Option c: Claiming that a business is carried on in a ‘business-like manner’ suggests a criterion based on appearance or method. While a business-like conduct can be indicative, the central issue in Ferguson v FCT concerns how the activity qualifies as carrying on a business for taxation purposes, not solely the manner in which it is conducted. This makes the statement incomplete or overly narrow as a description of the key issue.

Option d: Saying that, to be carrying on a business in common, the parties must be engaged in the same business, asserts a requirement of identical business activity. Ferguson v FCT addresses the broader question of whether carrying on a business can be established through common activity even if the ventures are not exactly the same, so this option introduces a too restrictive criterion and does not accurately capture the case’s scope.

In summary, option a correctly identifies the nuanced possibility that a single venture can satisfy the criterion of carrying on a business in certain circumstances, which is consistent with Ferguson v FCT. The other options misstate or oversimplify the legal tests for carrying on a business or partnership in the context discussed by the case.

MCD2070 - T3 - 2025 Partnership Quiz

What is the key issue in the case of Ferguson v FCT?

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

Partnership law in Australia is regulated by:

When a partner leaves a partnership:

Partnership law in Australia is regulated by:

Partnerships at will are not dissolved when a partner Blank ______ or enters bankruptcy. BlackTom题目解析

Under the Blank , a partner has a nontransferable interest in Blank . BlackTom题目解析

Under the RUPA, it is always possible for a partner to leave a firm when they want to. (Answer yes or no, and please explain.) BlackTom题目解析

更多留学生实用工具

考试浏览器助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单

MCD2070 - T3 - 2025 Partnership Quiz

What is the key issue in the case of Ferguson v FCT?

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

Partnership law in Australia is regulated by:

When a partner leaves a partnership:

Partnership law in Australia is regulated by:

Partnerships at will are not dissolved when a partner Blank ______ or enters bankruptcy. BlackTom题目解析

Under the Blank ______, a partner has a nontransferable interest in Blank ______. BlackTom题目解析

Under the RUPA, it is always possible for a partner to leave a firm when they want to. (Answer yes or no, and please explain.) BlackTom题目解析

更多留学生实用工具

希望你的学习变得更简单

Under the Blank , a partner has a nontransferable interest in Blank . BlackTom题目解析