Elbert's very complicated model with lots of features predicts the widgets in his warehouse very well! He's excited and decides to send out his predictive model to all the other warehouses in his company's vast network of warehouses so they can use it to predict how many widgets they need. Will his model work as well in predicting widgets in other warehouses?

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

In this scenario, Elbert’s model performs well on data from his own warehouse, but the key question is whether that performance will generalize to other warehouses.

Option 1: "Yes, his model has the lowest MSE!" This claims universal best performance based on the training data, which is a hallmark of overfitting. A model that fits its training set extremely well often captures noise or idiosyncrasies rather than underlying patterns that generalize. When you apply it to different warehouses with different data distributions, the MSE is unlikely to remain the lowest, and can actually worsen.

Option 2: "Yes, his model was quite complex, which leads to lower bias and better predictions at all warehouses" Here the implicit claim is that higher complexity reduces bias and improves generalization everywhere. In practice, increasing model complexity tends to reduce bias on the training data but increases variance, especially when applied to new data from different sources. This often hurts prediction accuracy in new warehouses due to overfitting to the training warehouse’s peculiarities.

Option 3: "No, his model likely was overfit to his warehouse data." This aligns with the common understanding in machine learning that a model that fits one dataset very closely may not generalize to others, particularly in a network of warehouses where demand patterns can differ by location, season, or other factors. Overfitting explains why performance can drop when deployed beyond the original data.

Putting these together, the first two options describe scenarios that misinterpret the generalization risk: either overclaiming performance on new data or asserting that complexity guarantees broad accuracy. The third option correctly identifies overfitting as the likely issue limiting cross-warehouse applicability, given the described context.

FA25_QTM_110_1 Quiz #11: Prediction, Machine Learning, and the Bias-Variance Tradeoff

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

In the above image, the prediction made at any value of X is shown by the blue line. This predictive model is an overfit for the training data.

Which one of the following linear discriminants is most prone to overfitting a training data set?

Overfitting (1 mark)What is overfitting?[Fill in the blank]

Which of the following conditions can lead to logistic regression overfitting the training data?

Question at position 6 True/False Question: There is no direct relationship between model complexity and overfitting. TrueFalse

A classifier shows 100% accuracy on the training set but performs poorly on new cases. What is most likely true?

更多留学生实用工具

考试浏览器助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单