The text suggests that the functions approach to describing managerial work is:

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

When evaluating statements about the functions approach to describing managerial work, it helps to compare it to alternative frameworks and consider what each model emphasizes.
Option 1: 'Outdated and no longer relevant.' This claim might arise if one believes that formal functions ignore the realities of modern, dynamic organizations. However, many texts still reference functions as a historical stepping-stone, even if they are not the preferred lens today. The option may overstate the disconnect with current practice.
Option 2: 'Only useful for top managers.' This is misleading because the functions approach aims to categorize managerial work at a broad level and is not limited to a single level of management. It can be applied conceptually to various managerial roles, though its descriptive power may vary by level.
Option 3: 'Less accurate than Mintzberg's roles.' This option contrasts two popular frameworks. Mintzberg’s roles (interpersonal, informational, decisional) aim to capture the actual activities and behaviors of managers observed in practice, offering a more nuanced and holistic view. The functions approach, by contrast, tends to describe managerial work in terms of broad, discrete functions (planning, organizing, leading, controlling), which may abstract away from how managers actually operate. Thus, many scholars and practitioners consider Mintzberg’s roles more descriptive of day-to-day activities, making this option plausible as a correct assessment.
Option 4: 'The generally accepted way.' This is unlikely given the prominence of Mintzberg’s framework and other contemporary approaches in management literature. The functions approach is not typically described as the generally accepted or dominant lens in modern texts.
In sum,Option 3 stands out as the most defensible evaluation: it acknowledges that Mintzberg’s roles provide a richer, more accurate depiction of managerial work for many contexts, whereas the functions approach may be seen as more limited or less precise in capturing actual managerial activity. The other options rest on claims that either overstate limitations, misstate applicability, or ignore prevailing scholarly consensus.

The text suggests that the functions approach to describing managerial work is:

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

Which of the following activities would be considered part of the human/interpersonal role of a manager?

One of Alan’s managerial roles is

Mintzberg’s roles of monitor, disseminator, and spokesperson are all related to which managerial responsibility?

According to Mintzberg's typology, a manager who decides to expand internationally to obtain new customers is a(n)

To be effective in the informational role as a manager, you would need which of the following skills?

One of Alan’s managerial roles is

One of Alan’s managerial roles is

Jack is a senior manager of marketing research at Tromex Enterprises, and calls in seven of his subordinates to brief them on his recent research findings regarding new machinery that might be relevant for Tromex. This is an example of a manager functioning in the role Mintzberg called the...

更多留学生实用工具

考试浏览器助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单