When discussing the topic of energy, it was shown that the hydrocarbon chains in gasoline and human fat look very similar and have other similarities:

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

To analyze the statement about energy and the comparison between hydrocarbon chains in gasoline and human fat, let's examine each option in turn with attention to what each claim implies.

Option 1: "All answers are correct". This would be true only if every other statement is accurate. We'll evaluate the others to see if they collectively hold. If any one of the other statements is flawed or misleading, this option would be incorrect.

Option 2: "Both have fairly high Atwater numbers". Atwater factors are a set of energy values assigned to macronutrients for human nutrition: roughly 4 kcal/g for carbohydrates and protein, and about 9 kcal/g for fats. These values are intended for biological food energy yeilds. Hydrocarbon chains in gasoline are not nutrients and are not assigned Atwater numbers; energy density in gasoline is described in terms of joules or calories per gram, but not via Atwater factors. Thus, asserting that both have fairly high Atwater numbers is problematic and can be considered inaccurate or misleading in a nutritional context. This option relies on applying Atwater numbers to substances (gasoline) for which they are not defined, so it is not a correct characterization.

Option 3: "Both are insoluble in water". Hydrocarbons are nonpolar and generally hydrophobic, so they do not dissolve in water. Human fats, which are largely triglycerides composed of long hydrocarbon chains, are likewise nonpolar and poorly soluble in water. Therefore, this statement is correct: both are insoluble in water, at least to a first approximation.

Option 4: "Both require oxygen to be utilized for energy". For fats in biology, energy release occurs via aerobic metabolism, which requires oxygen to oxidize fatty acids in mitochondria. For gasoline, energy release occurs via combustion, a chemical reaction with oxygen in the air that produces CO2, water, and energy. If the context is energy release (not biological metabolism) and we consider gasoline, oxygen is indeed required for energy release in combustion. Therefore, this statement is technically correct in the contexts of both biological fat energy and hydrocarbon combustion.

Putting the pieces together, the most defensible interpretation is that the insolubility in water (Option 3) and the oxygen-requiring energy release (Option 4) are correct. Option 2 is misleading because Atwater numbers apply to nutrients in foods, not to gasoline hydrocarbons, so claiming both have fairly high Atwater numbers is not accurate in standard nutrition terminology. Since one option (Option 2) is questionable and would render the composite claim of “All answers are correct” incorrect, we should not treat Option 1 as universally true. The reasoning shows that not all statements are equally valid in their standard contexts, so selecting “All answers are correct” would be inappropriate without caveats.

When discussing the topic of energy, it was shown that the hydrocarbon chains in gasoline and human fat look very similar and have other similarities:

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

A majority of the working dog's energy is derived from __________ metabolism.

Lipolysis refers to?

Lipids are the biomolecules of choice for storage of metabolic energy because they:

As a human goes into the starved state, the adipose - liver fatty acid / VLDL cycle (AKA "Dixon" cycle):

Excess and unused fatty acids carried by albumin are taken up by

Way after the meal is over, you are kept alive by the endogenous lipid cycle called

更多留学生实用工具

考试浏览器助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单