If we use agglomerative clustering on the same dataset multiple times, it's possible we get different clusters each time.

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Here's the statement to evaluate: 'If we use agglomerative clustering on the same dataset multiple times, it's possible we get different clusters each time.'

First, consider what agglomerative clustering involves. It is a hierarchical clustering method that starts with each data point as its own cluster and successively merges the closest pair of clusters according to a chosen linkage criterion (e.g., single, complete, average, Ward) and a distance metric.

In a deterministic implementation with fixed data, fixed distance function, and fixed linkage rule, the process is deterministic. This means that, given the same inputs and the same tie-breaking rules, you should obtain the same clustering results on every run.

However, there are realistic scenarios where you could see different clusters across runs. One cause is the choice of linkage criterion or distance metric being altered between runs, which changes how proximity and merging decisions are made.

Another common source of variability is tie-breaking nondeterminism. When two candidate merges have identical merge costs, the algorithm must choose one arbitrarily. If the implementation handles ties in a non-deterministic way (or if the order of data points influences the tie resolution), you can obtain different clusterings on different runs.

Additionally, if the dataset undergoes any preprocessing steps that introduce randomness (for example, random sampling, shuffling before processing that affects internal ordering, or stochastic data augmentation), the resulting clustering can vary.

There is also the practical possibility that parallelization or numerical precision differences across runs might lead to slight differences in merge decisions in some software implementations, again yielding different results.

To summarize, while the core algorithm is deterministic under fixed conditions, variability can arise from: changing linkage/distance settings, nondeterministic tie-breaking, or any randomness in preprocessing or computation. Consequently, the claim is not universally true; it is context-dependent.

Note: The provided answer options are not listed here, but the general conclusion aligns with common understanding: under strictly identical settings, agglomerative clustering should reproduce the same clustering; differences arise if any of the factors above differ between runs.

MISM2510.13156.202610

If we use agglomerative clustering on the same dataset multiple times, it's possible we get different clusters each time.

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

In hierarchical clustering using average linkage, if Cluster A = {1, 2} and Cluster B = {3, 4}, and the pairwise distances are:D(1,3)=2, D(1,4)=4, D(2,3)=6, D(2,4)= 8What is the average linkage distance between clusters A and B?

In hierarchical clustering using average linkage, if Cluster A = {1, 2} and Cluster B = {3, 4}, and the pairwise distances are:D(1,3)=2, D(1,4)=4, D(2,3)=6, D(2,4)= 8What is the average linkage distance between clusters A and B?

In hierarchical clustering using average linkage, if Cluster A = {1, 2} and Cluster B = {3, 4}, and the pairwise distances are:D(1,3)=2, D(1,4)=4, D(2,3)=6, D(2,4)= 8What is the average linkage distance between clusters A and B?

In hierarchical clustering using average linkage, if Cluster A = {1, 2} and Cluster B = {3, 4}, and the pairwise distances are:D(1,3)=2, D(1,4)=4, D(2,3)=6, D(2,4)= 8What is the average linkage distance between clusters A and B?

When using agglomerative clustering on this dataset, eventually we reach a point where there are 7 clusters. How many observations are in the biggest cluster?

When performing hierarchical clustering, which linkage method considers the maximum distance between points in two clusters?

更多留学生实用工具

考试浏览器助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单