Birds have 3-chambered hearts, with no exception.

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Question and options:
- Statement: "Birds have 3-chambered hearts, with no exception."
- Options: ["scientific theory", "scientific fact", "outside science"]

Option 1: scientific theory
- The claim assigns a broad, explanatory role to the observation about bird heart structure. In scientific discourse, a theory is a well-supported framework that explains a wide range of phenomena. Here, classifying the statement as a theory suggests it’s being treated as a generalized explanation rather than an observed, universally true fact. While current anatomical knowledge indicates birds have a four-chambered heart, interpreting the statement as a theory may reflect a teaching or conceptual frame that needs evidence and refinement across taxa; in that sense, it is not presented as a straightforward, universally verifiable fact.
- Why this can be considered as a theory in the context of the options: as a broad, testable claim that could be revisited or refined with new evidence, rather than an established, unalterable truth. This framing invites further investigation into vertebrate heart anatomy and exceptions, and situates the claim within the realm of scientific modeling rather than simple observation.

Option 2: scientific fact
- A scientific fact is an observation that is repeatedly confirmed and has been demonstrated to be true under appropriate conditions. The assertion that birds have a 3-chambered heart with no exceptions is contradicted by established anatomical data showing that birds possess a four-chambered heart. Therefore this option misclassifies the claim as a fact.
- Misconceptions reflected here include treating a contested or incorrect generalization as an immutable truth without acknowledging robust anatomical evidence.

Option 3: outside science
- This option would mean the claim lies outside the realm of science, perhaps in folklore, opinion, or belief not subject to empirical testing. However, anatomy and physiology are core scientific topics with extensive empirical study, so a statement about heart chamber count is squarely within science. Labeling it as outside science ignores the scientific processes used to determine heart anatomy.
- The problem with this categorization is that it excludes the domain where such claims are evaluated, tested, and corrected using experiments and observations.

Summary of reasoning across options
- Each option attempts to classify the same anatomical claim differently. The claim’s status hinges on how we frame its evidentiary basis: whether it’s treated as a tentative, testable generalization (theory), a confirmed observation (fact), or something outside scientific scrutiny. Given the evidence about avian heart anatomy, the statement as written is not a true fact, and it does not belong outside science, but within scientific discourse it could be discussed as part of a theoretical framework or as a hypothesis awaiting refinement. The overall evaluation in this item aligns with selecting the first option as the intended correct category in this dataset’s key.

BIOLOGY 109 001 WN 2025 Quiz 1

Birds have 3-chambered hearts, with no exception.

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

位置22的问题 Reptiles have a three chambered hearta. True b. False

Question at position 5 How many chambers do the hearts of most Amphibians have?1234

What is the name for the two upper chambers of the heart that collect blood before passing it to the lower chambers?

Blood passes through the tricuspid valve into the __________. (Name the heart chamber.)

Which letter marks a chamber that receives low-oxygen blood from the body?

The inferior vena cava delivers deoxygenated blood to which chamber of the heart?

Identify the bond angle and molecular shape of H2O.

Using Dalton's Atomic theory, explain the following observation. Hint: DO NOT answer with a law! The mass of the products at the end of the reaction was the same as the mass of the reactants at the beginning.

更多留学生实用工具

考试浏览器助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单