Which statement(s) best explain why Popper stressed falsifiability as well as testability for demarcating science from pseudo-science?

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

The question asks which statements help explain Popper’s emphasis on falsifiability in addition to testability for distinguishing science from pseudo-science.
Option 1: 'Some theories are falsifiable in principle but not testable in practice.' This captures a key practical concern Popper highlighted: a theory might be logically falsifiable (you could conceive a possible observation that would refute it) yet be so resistant to actual testing due to constraints like time, resources, or current technology that empirical disconfirmation cannot be pursued. This shows that merely being falsifiable is not enough unless testing is feasible, reinforcing the need for both falsifiability and the possibility of testing in practice.
Option 2: 'Some theories are testable but not falsifiable.' This points to the danger of theories that can be subjected to observation and experiments but are not falsifiable in principle, meaning there is no possible observation that could refute them. Popper argued that such theories fail the demarcation criterion because they do not expose themselves to potential refutation, and thus cannot be considered scientific in the strict sense. Recognizing this tension helps explain why testability alone is insufficient and why falsifiability is essential.
Both statements illustrate why Popper insisted on combining falsifiability with testability: the first emphasizes practical limits on testing while the second emphasizes the necessity of a genuine potential for refutation to avoid pseudo-science. The overall reasoning shows how each issue highlights shortcomings of theories that would otherwise slip outside rigorous scientific scrutiny.

SCIE20001_2025_SM2 Activity 1.3 Ungraded practice quiz

Which statement(s) best explain why Popper stressed falsifiability as well as testability for demarcating science from pseudo-science?

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

Falsifiability, which is one criterion of a useful theory, means that a theory can be proven right or wrong based on research findings or observations.

Which of the following is a NOT a strength of science?

For something to qualify as genuine scientific theory, it must be something that can potentially be proven either true or false.

For a concept or proposition to be a candidate for scientific theory, the concept must be capable of being proven true if it is true.

To properly evaluate a theory, you must ask: How can I prove this is wrong?

For something to qualify as genuine scientific theory, it must be something that can potentially be proven true.

A theory makes its predictions by telling you what will not be observed if it is correct.

A scientific hypothesis is________________, or capable of being shown to be incorrect.

更多留学生实用工具

考试浏览器助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单