Which statement best describes the treatment and control groups for this study?

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Restating the question: The prompt asks which statement best describes the treatment and control groups for this study.

Observations about the provided information: The only explicit option given is: "The treatment group was the 80 villages visited by recruiters, and the control group was the other 80 villages with no intervention." However, no other answer choices are supplied for comparison.

Analysis of the provided option:
- This statement defines two groups by exposure to an intervention: villages visited by recruiters constitute the treatment group, while the remaining 80 villages with no intervention form the control group. This is a common and plausible way to delineate groups in a field study where a subset of units receives an active intervention and the rest do not.
- It implies a cluster-level assignment (by village), which is typical in community-level or public health studies where individual randomization is impractical. If recruitment visits were planned and delivered to a subset of villages, this naturally creates a treatment vs. control contrast based on exposure.

Considerations that strengthen or weaken this description:
- Strength: Clear division into treated and untreated clusters (80 villages each) with a defined difference in exposure aligns with standard experimental or quasi-experimental designs, facilitating causal comparison of outcomes between treated and control groups.
- Potential weakness: The statement does not specify whether villages were randomized to receive recruiter visits or if assignment was observational or quasi-experimental. Without randomization, there could be baseline differences between villages that confound results. The description also does not indicate whether control villages received any form of minimal intervention, monitoring, or placebo contact, which could affect blinding and measurement.
- Additional details that would improve interpretation include: the randomization method (if used), whether sample sizes are balanced, whether baseline characteristics were measured and adjusted for, and how outcomes were assessed to minimize bias.

Why this option is reasonable as a description:
- It provides a straightforward, plausible operational definition of treatment and control groups, consistent with standard study designs where an intervention is selectively delivered to a subset (villages) and compared against non-exposed units.

Why one might question this option:
- If the study used individual randomization within villages, or if the intervention was delivered at a different unit of analysis (e.g., recruiters visiting certain households rather than entire villages), this description would be inaccurate.
- If there were any additional groups (e.g., a partial intervention, a placebo, or a secondary treatment) not mentioned, the statement would be incomplete.

In sum, given the single option provided, the described structure—treatment as villages visited by recruiters and control as the other villages with no intervention—fits a common approach to compare outcomes between exposed and unexposed clusters, provided randomization and other methodological details support valid comparison. The absence of other answer choices limits our ability to evaluate alternatives or identify potential biases beyond what the stated description implies.

CIS-124-HYA-CRN48380 Section 2 Practice

Which statement best describes the treatment and control groups for this study?

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

A clinical trial randomly assigns participants to a new treatment or placebo and measures blood pressure; the data collected is categorized as:

If you wanted two replicates per treatments, how many experimental units would you need? [ Select ] 8 12 27 x [ Select ] 1 2 3 = [ Select ] 12 24 36 experimental units

Question at position 11 Only two treatments should be used in an experiment.Each shrub did not receive all ten pruning methods.Pruning methods were not randomly assigned to shrubs.Each pruning method was used on only one shrub.The shrubs were not randomly selected.

更多留学生实用工具

考试浏览器助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单