Mencius is less idealistic than Confucius because he lived in a more chaotic time.

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

The prompt presents a claim about Mencius and Confucius: that Mencius is less idealistic than Confucius because he lived in a more chaotic time.
Option 1: True. This statement asserts that Mencius’s level of idealism was lower due to the chaotic era he inhabited. In examining classical Chinese philosophy, Confucius is traditionally portrayed as emphasizing moral ideals, virtue, and social harmony, while Mencius often argues that human nature is inherently good and that environments influence the flourishing of virtue. However, the claim that Mencius is definitively less idealistic than Confucius because of his historical context is an oversimplification. It presumes a direct causal link between external chaos and a person’s level of idealism, neglecting Mencius’s nuanced moral psychology and emphasis on benevolent governance regardless of era. Additionally, debates about “idealism” in their thought are not reducible to a simple temporal comparison; both philosophers articulate ideals, though they operationalize them in different settings and with different emphases. Therefore, this option relies on an incorrect cause-and-effect reading and overgeneralizes their positions.
Option 2: False. This statement denies the causal link proposed in the True option, suggesting that Mencius’s relative level of idealism cannot be straightforwardly attributed to the chaos of the era. Philosophically, Mencius is known for defending the inherent goodness of human nature and the importance of righteous leadership, which can be interpreted as a form of idealism aligned with his optimistic anthropology and political ethics. The question’s framing implies a direct, simplistic reduction: chaotic times automatically reduce idealism, which is not a universally accepted or necessary conclusion about Mencius or the nature of historical influence on philosophical stance. Thus, labeling the claim as false highlights that the relationship between historical context and a philosopher’s degree of idealism is more complex and not reducible to a single motivator. The distinction invites readers to consider how both thinkers frame ideals under differing circumstances and still maintain a robust normative project.
In sum, option-by-option, the True statement rests on an oversimplified causal narrative, while the False assessment reminds us that the comparison of idealism between Confucius and Mencius cannot be cleanly attributed to chaos of their times alone, and their thought resists such a blunt temporal reduction.

Spr25_CHIN012_36029 2.3.7.1: Quiz on Mencius and His Thoughts

Mencius is less idealistic than Confucius because he lived in a more chaotic time.

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

Question at position 28 In Confucian philosophy, the concept of ren primarily refers to:Humaneness or benevolenceHarmony with natureRitual proprietyFilial pietyUniversal law

Question at position 7 Harmony in relationships and cultivation of moral virtues Eternal punishment and divine salvationAsceticism and rejection of worldly dutiesRationalism and mathematical order Individualism and detachment from society

(18) T/F: Eve’s statements about what it means to be a gentleman is supported by the writings of Xunzi.

According to the reading and film on Confucian thought, Confucius taught the principle of reciprocity or the Golden Rule (do unto others as you want them to do unto you...paraphrased biblical reference).

The ideal ruler in Confucianism can morally influence, improve and transform his people.

Confucius believes that social order must be established and maintained through political hierarchy.

In an ideal Confucian state, a ruler must be virtuous and rule by example, and the subjects are all willing to follow the good example set by the ruler.

According to Confucius, virtue itself constitutes power.

更多留学生实用工具

考试浏览器助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单