Spite is common among many animals.

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

The statement under consideration is: 'Spite is common among many animals.' The two answer options are:
- True
- False

Option 1: True
- A common-sense reading might suggest that animals sometimes act to hurt others without apparent benefit, which could be interpreted as spite. However, in scientific terms, many such behaviors are better explained by alternative motives such as competition, misdirected aggression, or selfish genetic strategies rather than genuine spite. Spite implies a costly action toward another at a potential personal cost with no clear benefit to the actor, and proving this in animals is difficult because researchers must rule out benefits or mistaken interpretations of the behavior.
- Additionally, what looks like spite could often be understood through evolutionary explanations like resource defense, social dynamics, or inadvertent harm from normal aggressive or submissive interactions. Therefore, labeling spite as common across many species overstates the available evidence and oversimplifies the diverse motivational landscapes observed in animal behavior.

Option 2: False
- This option aligns with current behavioral science views, which generally treat spite as a rare or controversial attribution rather than a widespread phenomenon. Demonstrating genuine spite requires showing that the action reduces another’s fitness while also not increasing the actor’s own fitness, which is a stringent condition that is not routinely satisfied in natural observations. Many scientists prefer to categorize such actions under well-supported explanations like competition, territory defense, or coercive social strategies, rather than attributing them to spite.
- In short, the claim that spite is common across many animals conflicts with the nuanced understanding that animal behavior tends to be explained by functional motives with measurable consequences, rather than by an abstract human-like notion of spite being widespread.

Summary of reasoning across options
- The 'True' option risks conflating observed antagonistic interactions with the specific, costly, spiteful motive that lacks obvious benefit, which is rarely demonstrated in comparative studies.
- The 'False' option more accurately captures the cautious interpretation most researchers adopt, acknowledging that spite is not broadly evidenced as a common, across-species phenomenon.

Overall, evaluating the evidence suggests the statement is not supported by broad, consistent findings in animal behavior, supporting the interpretation that the claim is false.

ANTH 1050-090 Fall 2025 Exam 2

Spite is common among many animals.

查看解析

登录即可查看完整答案

类似问题

38. A feral cat

Frogs are most active during the day

Mother hamsters are prone to ________, especially with their first litter

Do the following traits/ behaviors best characterize humans, chimps, or both? Use body language to communicate [ Select ] Humans Chimps Both

Do the following traits/ behaviors best characterize humans, chimps, or both? Can learn sign language [ Select ] Humans Chimps Both

The article Whose Life Would You Save suggests that like humans, some species of monkeys appear to have a sense of fairness.

Aggression in the form of raids is practiced by...

Question at position 39 Why do bees alter the angle of their waggle dance throughout the day when describing a food location?To confuse rival coloniesBecause they get tiredTo trick predatorsTo compensate for solar movement

更多留学生实用工具

考试浏览器助手

风格化写作助手

论文查重助手

文献引用助手

课堂转译助手

课堂笔记助手

Quiz搜索助手

学校历年真题

智能刷题助手

智能匹配练习

希望你的学习变得更简单