Question at position 17 17. In which sentence did the boy's girlfriend come over while he was cleaning? (Choose the sentence that is grammatically correct & shows this meaning) He was cleaning when she coming.He cleaned when she came over.He cleaning while she visiting.He was cleaning when she visited.

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Question restatement: In which sentence did the boy's girlfriend come over while he was cleaning? (Choose the sentence that is grammatically correct & shows this meaning)

Option 1: 'He was cleaning when she coming.' This is incorrect because after 'when', the verb 'come' should be in a past tense form to match the time frame. The correct continuous past form would be 'was coming' or, more naturally in this context, use the past simple 'came' to indicate an interruption. Therefore, 'coming' is ungrammatical here.

Option 2: 'He cleaned when she came over.' This sentence is grammatically correct and uses past simple for both actions. It indicates that his cleaning happened at the time she came over, but it describes two discrete past actions rather than a continuous past action occurring during another past action. It conveys a related meaning but not the ongoing action during the cleaning as emphasized by 'was cleaning.'

Option 3: 'He cleaning while she visiting.' This is ungrammatical. The verb 'cleaning' lacks a helping verb (should be 'was cleaning'), and 'visiting' lacks a corresponding auxiliary (should be 'was visiting' or 'visited'). As written, it violates standard English syntax.

Option 4: 'He was cleaning when she visited.' This sentence is grammatically correct. It uses the past continuous 'was cleaning' to express ongoing action in the past, and the past simple 'visited' to denote the completed action of visiting that occurred during that ongoing activity. This construction cleanly captures the meaning 'she came over while he was cleaning.'

Summary of correctness reasoning: The intended meaning requires an ongoing past action ('was cleaning') simultaneous with a past action by the girlfriend ('visited' or 'came over'). Among the options, only Option 4 preserves the continuous aspect of his cleaning while aligning with the timing of her visiting, making it the grammatically correct and meaning-appropriate choice. Option 2, while grammatically valid, portrays two separate past events without the continuous aspect, which reduces its alignment with the requested meaning. Options 1 and 3 are grammatical mistakes that violate tense or structure.

Note on nuance: If you specifically want 'came over' as the phrase for the girlfriend’s action, you could rephrase the correct structure as 'He was cleaning when she came over,' which would still be correct and natural; however, in the given option list, 'He was cleaning when she visited.' best matches the continuous action during her arrival using the supplied choices.

View Explanation

Log in for full answers

Similar Questions

Question at position 38 38. Is this sentence grammatically correct or incorrect? I am studying when you called. I should practice more EnglishI don't knowincorrectcorrect

Question at position 36 36. They ___________________ (build) a new cafeteria last month.Question Blank 1 of 1[input]

Question at position 19 19. He (break) his leg when he (skateboard). was breaking, was skateboardingbroke, was skateboardingbreak, was skateboardingbreaked, was skateboardingbroke, skateboarding

Question at position 16 16. Yesterday I (go) outside and I _(take) a walk. went, takinggo, takingwent, tookgoes, tookgo, take

Question at position 15 15. ___ (do) you (hear) about the big storm yesterday? Yes, I _(see) the videos when I ____(turn) on the news. Didn't, hear, see, turnedDid, heard, saw, turnedDo, hear, saw, turnedDoesn't, hear, saw, turnedDid, hear, saw, turned

Question at position 12 12. I _________ English at Fairmont Prep this year. 'm studyingdo studyingalways studyingstudyingstudies

More Practical Tools for Students Powered by AI Study Helper

Homework AI Solver

Stylized AI Paper Writer

Plagiarism Checker Assistant

Citation AI Academic Writing Tool

In-Class Translation Assistant

AI Note Generator

AI Quiz Answers

Past Exam Questions from University Test Bank

Smart Practice Assistant

Adaptive Practice

Making Your Study Simpler