In a vintage science fiction movie, space travelers find themselves on a planet orbiting a distant star in which there are curious forms of life based on silicon instead of carbon. Although the story clearly is a sci-fi, the choice of silicon as this alien life-form's central atom instead of carbon, seems plausible or credible, because silicon has 14 protons. This means that silicon

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

This question centers on the chemical basis for why silicon could be imagined as carbon-like in sci‑fi life forms.
Option 1: 'has 4 electrons in its valence shell and thus can form 4 bonds as carbon' — This is the accurate explanation. Silicon (like carbon) has four valence electrons, which allows it to form up to four covalent bonds, a key reason scientists sometimes speculate about carbon-like chemistry for silicon-based life. The idea hinges on valence electron configuration rather than just the total number of protons.
Option 2: 'has one more proton than carbon, so shares similar properties of carbon' — Merely having one more proton does not guarantee similar chemistry. Chemical properties are dominated by electron arrangements, especially valence electrons, and silicon's chemistry diverges from carbon in several respects (bond strengths, preferred oxidation states, etc.), despite a similar group position in the periodic table.
Option 3: 'is an isotope of carbon so, shares similar chemical properties of carbon' — This is false. Silicon is not an isotope of carbon; they are distinct elements with different atomic numbers and electron configurations. Isotopes differ in neutron numbers, not in identity as separate elements with different chemical behavior.
Option 4: 'is heavier than carbon and thus, shares similar properties of carbon' — Being heavier does not confer carbon-like chemistry. Mass alone does not determine valence behavior or bonding patterns. Silicon’s chemistry is influenced by its larger atomic size and orbital energies, which alter bond strengths and preferred structures.
Option 5: 'has 6 electrons as carbon and thus, shares similar properties of carbon' — Carbon has 6 electrons total, but what matters for bonding is the number of valence electrons, which for silicon is 4, not 6. This statement misstates silicon’s electron count and would lead to incorrect conclusions about bonding capacity.

View Explanation

Log in for full answers

Similar Questions

The number of valence electrons in a sulfur atom is 16.

The number of valence electrons in one carbonate ion (CO32-) is

How many valence electrons does an arsenic (As) atom have? (Input number only.)

Identify the number of valence electrons for each of the following neutral atoms. Type a number (5) into each of the boxes. Do NOT enter a word (seven). Mg = [Fill in the blank] Ge = [Fill in the blank] Cl = [Fill in the blank] 19A

How many valence electrons are in the electron-dot structure of SeF2?

Consider the electron configuration of the following atomsI Galium, GaII Calcium, CaIII Iron, FeWhich atom(s) have 2 electrons in the outer shell in their ground state?

Question at position 23 How many electrons should tellurium (Te) have around its Lewis Dot model? 1 3 5 2 6 4

Identify the number of valence electrons for each of the following neutral atoms. Type a number (5) into each of the boxes. Do NOT enter a word (seven). Mg = [Fill in the blank], Ge = [Fill in the blank], Cl = [Fill in the blank], 19A

More Practical Tools for International Students

Exam Browser Assistant

Stylized Writing Assistant

Plagiarism Checker Assistant

Citation Assistant

In-Class Translation Assistant

Class Notes Assistant

Quiz Search Assistant

Past Exam Questions by School

Smart Practice Assistant

Adaptive Practice

Making Your Study Simpler