Which group of organisms should be rarest in any ecosystem, and why?

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Question restatement: Which group of organisms should be rarest in any ecosystem, and why?
Option A: Primary consumers, as they are susceptible to predation by both secondary and tertiary consumers. While predation pressure can affect their numbers, primary consumers are typically more abundant than higher trophic levels because plants (producers) form the base of the energy pyramid and can support many herbivores. This statement overemphasizes predation as the sole limiting factor and does not reflect the general energy distribution across trophic levels.
Option B: Primary Consumers, as they are limited by the number of plants, especially in winter. Seasonal plant availability can influence herbivore populations temporarily, but the broader ecological rule is about energy transfer efficiency rather than plant quantity alone. Herbivores are not universally limited to winter dynamics; they can persist when plants are available, and energy losses still govern abundance patterns across levels.
Option C: Producers, as they can only produce at certain times of year. Producers (primarily photosynthetic organisms) can often produce continuously or seasonally, depending on the ecosystem, but the ultimate reason for rarity across trophic levels is not about the timing of production alone. Even if production is seasonal, the general energy pyramid concept emphasizes how much energy is available to higher levels, not just seasonal production windows.
Option D: Tertiary Consumers, as energy is lost at each trophic level, leaving less available at the top. This aligns with the fundamental ecological principle: energy transfer between trophic levels is inefficient (roughly 10% often cited), causing higher trophic levels to have far fewer individuals and biomass. Consequently, tertiary consumers are typically the rarest group in most ecosystems due to cumulative energy losses from producers up through consumers.
Synthesis: The core idea is the diminishing energy transfer as you move up the food chain, which makes top predators (tertiary consumers) the least abundant. The other options misattribute rarity to predation pressure, seasonal plant availability, or production timing without addressing the universal energy pyramid constraint. The mismatch in these explanations explains why those options generally fail to account for the observed patterns of ecosystem structure.

ENVIR 100 (Sp25) Exam 3

Which group of organisms should be rarest in any ecosystem, and why?

View Explanation

Log in for full answers

Similar Questions

Sort from higher (1) to lower (4) levels of energy for the following organisms in a given trophic web. 1: 1 2: 2 3: 3 4: 4

About .001 of the energy captured by photosynthesis passes through to __________.

Energy available in an ecosystem is usually depicted in the shape of a pyramid. The tip of this pyramid represents which group of organisms?

A species which main source of energy originates from autotrophs is referred as:

The trophic levels of an ecosystem are typically shaped like a pyramid because:

What is each level or "link" in a food chain or a food web called?

If the flow of energy in an arctic ecosystem goes through a simple food chain, perhaps involving humans, starting from phytoplankton to zooplankton to fish to seals to polar bears, then which of the following could be TRUE?

Organisms that break down dead organic tissue and return it to the short term carbon cycle, thereby providing a very important ecosystem service are referred to as in food webs, while organisms that photosynthesize and are eaten by primary consumers are referred to as .

More Practical Tools for Students Powered by AI Study Helper

Homework AI Solver

Stylized AI Paper Writer

Plagiarism Checker Assistant

Citation AI Academic Writing Tool

In-Class Translation Assistant

AI Note Generator

AI Quiz Answers

Past Exam Questions from University Test Bank

Smart Practice Assistant

Adaptive Practice

Making Your Study Simpler