If a scholar says there is an 80% chance that Shakespeare wrote the play Macbeth, what does this most likely mean?

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

The task presents a question about how to interpret a probability statement regarding authorship. 
Option 1: 'By the definition of what Macbeth is, there is an 80% chance that Shakespeare wrote it.' This is conflating content or genre with probability; it suggests a definitional certainty rather than expressing a degree of belief about authorship. It doesn’t capture the idea that the 80% reflects a scholar's confidence, not a property of the play itself. 
Option 2: 'The scholar’s degree of belief that Shakespeare wrote Macbeth is 80%'. This is the correct interpretation in a probabilistic sense: the statistic communicates the scholar’s subjective probability or degree of belief that Shakespeare is the author, given the evidence. It treats probability as a measure of belief about a proposition, not a claim about factual frequency or a process. 
Option 3: '80% of scholars think that Shakespeare wrote Macbeth'. This misreads the statement as a population frequency or consensus among scholars, implying a survey result rather than an individual degree of belief. A single 80% belief by one scholar does not imply 80% of all scholars share that belief. 
Option 4: 'If you were able to run simulations of history, then in 80% of the simulations Shakespeare writes Macbeth'. This frames the probability as a long-run frequency outcome from simulations of history, which is a modeling approach rather than a direct expression of a scholar’s current belief about authorship. It adds an artificial methodological layer that isn’t inherent in the original statement. 
Option 5: '80% of the words in Macbeth were written by Shakespeare'. This is a completely different and implausible claim about authorship attribution at the word level, which is not what a probability of authorship conveys.
Overall, the only interpretation that aligns with probabilistic language about belief in a proposition is Option 2, while the other options misinterpret what the 80% statistic is signaling or rely on a different inferential framework.

ATHK1X01 Mastery Quiz 03

If a scholar says there is an 80% chance that Shakespeare wrote the play Macbeth, what does this most likely mean?

View Explanation

Log in for full answers

Similar Questions

Belinda Boyd is reviewing a newly proposed advertising campaign. Based on her 15 years' experience, she believes the campaign has a 75% chance of significantly increasing brand name recognition of the product. This is an example of assigning probabilities by the ________________ method.

If a scholar says there is an 80% chance that Shakespeare wrote the play Macbeth, what does this most likely mean?

A dam on a river that holds back a water reservoir begins to leak. Engineers say that there is a 10 percent chance of the dam breaking if repairs are not made. This is an example of ________.

Subjective evaluation of probabilities can exhibit

In a consumer society, many adults channel creativity into buying things

Economic stress and unpredictable times have resulted in a booming industry for self-help products

People born without creativity never can develop it

More Practical Tools for Students Powered by AI Study Helper

Homework AI Solver

Stylized AI Paper Writer

Plagiarism Checker Assistant

Citation AI Academic Writing Tool

In-Class Translation Assistant

AI Note Generator

AI Quiz Answers

Past Exam Questions from University Test Bank

Smart Practice Assistant

Adaptive Practice

Making Your Study Simpler