In section 3. Computers are Superior to Humans (Subtlety), J.K. Riki quotes animator Tom Bancroft. Which of the following communicates Bancroft's opinion of the value of 3D (CG) animation?

Question

In section 3. Computers are Superior to Humans (Subtlety), J.K. Riki quotes animator Tom Bancroft.  Which of the following communicates Bancroft's opinion of the value of 3D (CG) animation?

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

First, restate the question and options to ensure clarity about what’s being evaluated.
Question: In section 3. Computers are Superior to Humans (Subtlety), J.K. Riki quotes animator Tom Bancroft. Which of the following communicates Bancroft's opinion of the value of 3D (CG) animation?
Answer options:
A) Subtle acting can be better achieved with CG animation.
B) 2D animation acting works better with broader performances
C) Ultra realistic animation performances, like those created in CG, can look like live action, and lose the magic of animation
D) All of the above statements summarize Bancroft's opinion of CG animation

Analysis of each option:
Option A: Subtle acting can be better achieved with CG animation.
- This suggests that Bancroft believes CG enables more nuanced or subtle performance, which is a common claim associated with the precision and capabilities of CG rigs, motion capture, or fine-tuned facial animation. The reasoning would be that CG allows animators to craft delicate expressions and timing that can enhance subtle acting. However, one must consider whether Bancroft explicitly stated that subtlety is uniquely or especially achievable with CG, or if he claimed CG excels in some dimensions while not addressing others.
- Implications: If Bancroft emphasizes the strengths of CG for subtler performances, this option aligns with a positive view of CG’s expressive potential. If he did not specifically advocate for subtlety as a CG advantage, this option could be an overreach.

Option B: 2D animation acting works better with broader performances.
- This option asserts that traditional 2D animation is better suited to broader or more exaggerated acting styles. The claim contrasts CG with 2D, suggesting a preference for 2D in expansive, perhaps more cartoony or stagey performances. Bancroft’s stance would need to clearly privilege 2D for broad acting while downplaying CG in that respect. If Bancroft argued that CG narrows the expressive range or that 2D is superior for broad acting, this would support the option. If instead he argued that CG can also perform broadly or that 2D isn’t inherently superior for broad acts, this option would be weaker.
- Implications: This option is plausible only if Bancroft explicitly frames 2D as better for broad acting, or if he positions CG as not optimal for that style.

Option C: Ultra realistic animation performances, like those created in CG, can look like live action, and lose the magic of animation.
- This captures a common critique that hyper-realistic CG can blur the line with live action and potentially diminish the distinct, magical feel of traditional animation. If Bancroft warned that extreme realism in CG might erode the whimsical or stylized qualities of animation, this would reflect a cautious stance on realism in CG. This option line up with a nuanced view that CG has benefits but also risks.
- Implications: If Bancroft indeed warned about losing magic due to realism, this would strongly suggest a negative caveat about CG’s impact on animation magic. If he did not mention realism effects or magic loss, this would be less supported.

Option D: All of the above statements summarize Bancroft's opinion of CG animation
- This option claims that A, B, and C are all correct as representations of Bancroft’s view. For this to be true, each of A, B, and C would need to be individually accurate characterizations of his stance. Given the analyses of A, B, and C, this would require that Bancroft both champions CG for subtle acting, favors 2D for broad acting, and also cautions that hyper-real CG can lose animation’s magic.
- Implications: The legitimacy of D hinges on whether A, B, and C are all individually defensible as accurate reflections of Bancroft’s opinion. If any one of A, B, or C is not supported by his statements, D would be incorrect.

Overall assessment: Each option presents a distinct facet of possible viewpoints about CG animation. The correct interpretation depends on the exact wording Bancroft used in the cited section. Option A emphasizes CG’s capacity for subtlety, Option B emphasizes a perceived advantage of 2D for broad acting, and Option C cautions about realism potentially reducing animation’s magical quality. Option D requires that all three earlier claims are simultaneously valid as Bancroft’s communicated stance. Without the precise textual citation, one should weigh how strongly Bancroft endorsed CG’s expressive precision (A), whether he positioned 2D as superior for broad performances (B), and whether he warned against over-realism diminishing animation’s charm (C) to decide if D holds. The key misconception to avoid is assuming Bancroft endorses all three aspects uniformly without direct quotation.

25SP_GD1_11380 Quiz_09 - Pixels vs Pencils

In section 3. Computers are Superior to Humans (Subtlety), J.K. Riki quotes animator Tom Bancroft. Which of the following communicates Bancroft's opinion of the value of 3D (CG) animation?

View Explanation

Log in for full answers

Similar Questions

In a consumer society, many adults channel creativity into buying things

Economic stress and unpredictable times have resulted in a booming industry for self-help products

People born without creativity never can develop it

A product has a selling price of $20, a contribution margin ratio of 40% and fixed cost of $120,000. To make a profit of $30,000. The number of units that must be sold is: Type the number without $ and a comma. Eg: 20000

Which of the following statement regarding cost is correct:

Under the assumptions used in cost-volume-profit analysis, as the activity increases:

The CVP and break-even analysis are supported by a range of important assumptions. Which of the following is not an assumption of the CVP:

The break-even point is that at which:

More Practical Tools for Students Powered by AI Study Helper

Homework AI Solver

Stylized AI Paper Writer

Plagiarism Checker Assistant

Citation AI Academic Writing Tool

In-Class Translation Assistant

AI Note Generator

AI Quiz Answers

Past Exam Questions from University Test Bank

Smart Practice Assistant

Adaptive Practice

Making Your Study Simpler