Select the most appropriate response:

J. Marion Simms performed experimental surgeries on enslaved women called Betsy, Anarcha and Lucy...

Question

Select the most appropriate response:

J. Marion Simms performed experimental surgeries on enslaved women called Betsy, Anarcha and Lucy...

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

The question asks you to select the most appropriate response regarding the historical conduct of J. Marion Sims in surgeries performed on enslaved women named Betsy, Anarcha, and Lucy.
Option 1: 'Without their consent' — This statement is historically supported, as consent from enslaved individuals or their families was neither sought nor legally required in that context, reflecting the broader coercive and exploitative practices of the era.
Option 2: 'Without anesthesia' — Historical records indicate that many such procedures were carried out without adequate anesthesia for enslaved patients, often under harsh and inhumane conditions, which contributed to extreme pain and harm.
Option 3: 'All of the above' — This option asserts that both lack of consent and lack of anesthesia apply, and in many accounts, repeated procedures were performed on the same individuals, highlighting a pattern of experimental surgeries without proper patient rights or relief.
Option 4: 'Multiple times' — There are accounts that these surgeries were repeated on Betsy, Anarcha, and Lucy, sometimes across several sessions, which underscores the persistent and invasive nature of the experiments.

To understand why the options relate to each other, consider that the historical context involved exploitation, absence of informed consent, and procedures conducted without standard medical protections like anesthesia, often repeated across multiple operations. Each of the first two statements describes a component of the broader pattern, while the third encapsulates them together and aligns with the cumulative practice described. The fourth option points to repetition, which is a separate aspect of the same history and can be true alongside the first and second.

In evaluating the choices, one should weigh whether an option adequately captures the full scope described. Since the situation involved both lack of consent and lack of anesthesia, and often repeated procedures, the option that aggregates these points (and acknowledges repetition) provides a comprehensive summary of the described conduct. The other options capture individual elements, but do not account for the full set of practices collectively. By analyzing each item this way, you can see how they fit into the overall historical pattern and why a broader combined statement accurately reflects the described events.

SP26_SON_ISJ_Nursing_Requirement Historical Foundations of Racial Disparities Quiz

Select the most appropriate response: J. Marion Simms performed experimental surgeries on enslaved women called Betsy, Anarcha and Lucy...

View Explanation

Log in for full answers

Similar Questions

Question at position 9 Q9 Hall (consent)YesNo

Informed consent is when a patient is provided with all the risks, benefits, and alternatives for a procedure, intervention, or medication and discussion is facilitated as needed in order to make a decision.

Failing to obtain informed consent before treatment can lead to:

Cost of treatment is NOT a component of which of the following?

All of the following are components of informed consent except one. Which is the exception?

Informed consent is...

Failing to obtain informed consent before treatment can lead to:

More Practical Tools for Students Powered by AI Study Helper

Homework AI Solver

Stylized AI Paper Writer

Plagiarism Checker Assistant

Citation AI Academic Writing Tool

In-Class Translation Assistant

AI Note Generator

AI Quiz Answers

Past Exam Questions from University Test Bank

Smart Practice Assistant

Adaptive Practice

Making Your Study Simpler