In the Prisoner’s Dilemma, whatever choice the other guy makes, the payoff for you is to always
[ Select ]
Cooperate
Defect

Question

In the Prisoner’s Dilemma, whatever choice the other guy makes, the payoff for you is to always 
[ Select ]
Cooperate
Defect

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

In this question, we are considering the classic Prisoner's Dilemma and the prompt asks you to fill in the blank: 'In the Prisoner’s Dilemma, whatever choice the other guy makes, the payoff for you is to always [Select] Cooperate Defect.'

Option: Cooperate
- If the other player cooperates, choosing to cooperate yields a moderate reward, while defecting would typically yield a higher payoff for you if the matrix is standard (e.g., you get the same or more by defecting). However, the key point in the dilemma is that your best reply, given the other player’s possible actions, is not to rely on cooperation alone. Cooperation can be exploited by a defecting partner, reducing trust and mutual benefit. So 'Cooperate' is not the dominant strategy that guarantees the highest payoff regardless of the other player's move.

Option: Defect
- If the other player cooperates, defecting gives you the highest individual payoff (you capitalize on their cooperation). If the other player defects, defecting still gives you a payoff that is at least as good as, and usually better than, cooperating. This makes 'Defect' the dominant strategy: it yields the best or equal-best outcome regardless of the opponent’s action. From a game-theoretic standpoint, this is why the Nash equilibrium of the Prisoner’s Dilemma is Defect-Defect.

Why Defect is the correct understanding here: the phrase 'whatever choice the other guy makes' points to a strategy that does not depend on the other player's action, i.e., a dominant strategy. In the standard payoff structure, defecting dominates cooperating because it provides protection against the risk of being exploited and still offers a higher payoff if the other player cooperates. Therefore, the payoff for you is to always Defect in this framing.

Why Cooperate is not the right universal move: while cooperating might lead to mutual benefit if both players choose it, it is not robust to the possibility that the other player defects. If you always cooperate while the other defects, you end up with the worst payoff for yourself, creating an incentive to defect as well. The dilemma hinges on this tension between short-term individual gain and protection against exploitation, which is why cooperation is not the universal best response in the standard setup.

In sum, the reasoning reflects the core concept of the Prisoner’s Dilemma: Defect is the dominant strategy, providing the best payoff across possible actions by the other player, whereas Cooperation cannot guarantee a better outcome in all cases and is therefore not the universally optimal response.

ANTH 1050-090 Fall 2025 Exam 2

In the Prisoner’s Dilemma, whatever choice the other guy makes, the payoff for you is to always [ Select ] Cooperate Defect

View Explanation

Log in for full answers

Similar Questions

Consider the game described by the following payoff matrix. Which of the following statements is TRUE? Player 2 Left Middle Right Player 1 Top 25, 30 16, 32 30, 23 Center 34, 43 18, 23 35, 12 Bottom 43, 15 21, 33 36, 38

Consider the game described by the following payoff matrix. Which of the following statements is TRUE? Player 2 Left Middle Right Player 1 Top 25, 30 16, 32 30, 23 Center 34, 43 18, 23 35, 12 Bottom 43, 15 21, 33 36, 38

Consider the following game: Player B Accept Reject Accept 5, 6 13, 3 Player A Reject 7, 5 8, 4 What is the maximum A is willing to offer to B if it plays Reject? (Note: if it must be less than 10, enter 10)

Consider the following game. Player B Accept Reject Accept 5, 7 13, X Player A Reject 7, 9 X, 6 What should be the minimum possible value of X for this game to be a Coordination Game? (Note: if it must be higher than 10, enter 10)

The table below is not a game in strategic form because the payoffs should be different for the different actions U and D. [table] U | (1,1) | (0,0) D | (0,0) | (0,0) [/table]

In a two-player strategic form game there are two numbers at each entry in the payoff matrix. The first of these numbers is usually the payoff of the column player.

Question at position 37 Which of the following is a theory that studies the interactions between two parties that compete and/or cooperate with each other? Predatory pricing theoryGame theoryPrisoner's dilemma theoryCross-market retaliation theory

More Practical Tools for Students Powered by AI Study Helper

Homework AI Solver

Stylized AI Paper Writer

Plagiarism Checker Assistant

Citation AI Academic Writing Tool

In-Class Translation Assistant

AI Note Generator

AI Quiz Answers

Past Exam Questions from University Test Bank

Smart Practice Assistant

Adaptive Practice

Making Your Study Simpler