The rules to interpreting exclusions clauses include the ambiguity rule, negligence rule, presumption against fundamental breach and four corners rule.

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

The statement presents a list of rules for interpreting exclusion clauses and asks whether it is true or false.
Option True: If we evaluate each component, we see that ambiguity rule and four corners rule are commonly cited concepts in contract interpretation, and there is a recognized presumption against fundamental breach in some contexts. However, the term 'negligence rule' is not a standard, widely accepted rule of interpreting exclusion clauses. This makes the overall claim unreliable, as one item in the list is not part of the established framework.
Option False: The flaw lies in the inclusion of the 'negligence rule.' While ambiguity, the four corners rule, and the presumption against fundamental breach are recognizable notions in contract interpretation, there is no well-established 'negligence rule' driving how exclusion clauses are interpreted. Therefore, the statement as a whole is not accurate, since it misstates the established set of interpretive rules.
In summary, the presence of an incorrect element ('negligence rule') renders the entire statement inaccurate, even though the other elements have some basis in interpretation principles. The incorrect option is the True one because the list is not correct as stated.

MCD2070 - T3 - 2025 Express Terms and Exemption Clauses Quiz

The rules to interpreting exclusions clauses include the ambiguity rule, negligence rule, presumption against fundamental breach and four corners rule.

View Explanation

Log in for full answers

Similar Questions

This case concluded that under the ambiguity rule, an exemption clause that excludes liability for breach of warranty will not be sufficient against liability for breach of condition.

A parking lot who is liable for negligence CANNOT be sued if the exclusion clause states: “Cars parked at owner’s risk. No liability is accepted for any damage caused to any person, vehicle or visitor howsoever caused.”