The Broadway Café has been the only coffee shop in its neighborhood since 1952, but with a Starbucks opening nearby, your employees are worried about competition—what is the best strategy to maintain a competitive advantage using business intelligence?

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

Contextualizing the scenario, the café faces new competition and should rely on business intelligence to sustain a competitive edge rather than simplistic, high-risk moves.
Option 1: 'Leverage customer data to create a loyalty program and emphasize the café's unique local charm' This aligns with BI practices: collecting and analyzing customer data to tailor a loyalty program, enhance retention, and differentiate through local branding and experience. It utilizes data-driven insights to reward repeat customers and highlight strengths that a chain like Starbucks may not replicate easily—community feel, local flavor, personalized service.
Option 2: 'Lower prices drastically to undercut Starbucks, even if it reduces profit margins significantly' While price competition is a tactic, data-driven BI would caution against aggressive discounting that erodes margins. It may win short-term customers but risks unsustainable profits and devalues the brand. BI would instead test price elasticity and promotions to preserve profitability while remaining competitive.
Option 3: 'Wait until Starbucks opens and monitor their success before making any changes to the business model' This is a passive approach. BI emphasizes proactive analysis and rapid iteration; waiting yields opportunity costs and can cede market share without leveraging data to adapt quickly.
Option 4: 'Increase prices without changing the menu to give the perception of a premium coffee experience' Price increases without corresponding value signals or data-backed rationale can backfire, harming demand. BI would require evidence that customers perceive added value and would sustain higher prices; otherwise this could alienate price-sensitive segments.
Overall, the strongest BI-informed strategy is option 1 because it uses data to create a loyalty program and leverages the cafe’s local charm to differentiate in a way that is sustainable and defensible against a larger competitor.

The Broadway Café has been the only coffee shop in its neighborhood since 1952, but with a Starbucks opening nearby, your employees are worried about competition—what is the best strategy to maintain a competitive advantage using business intelligence?

View Explanation

Log in for full answers

Similar Questions

Which of the following is most likely to lead to high levels of customer loyalty?

True or False? It is great to have satisfied customers, but even better to have loyal customers.

Which of the following statements about loyalty programs is false?

Carlos regularly buys coffee from a local café instead of Starbucks, even though Starbucks offers rewards. He explains that the baristas at the café know his name and remember his favorite drink, which makes him feel valued. Which factor best explains Carlos’s loyalty?

When Starbucks uses its app to send personalized offers to frequent buyers, this encourages:

Consumer loyalty can often drive profits and growth.

The role of marketing and advertising is not only to convey information about a product or service’s features but also to build an emotional bond with customers to create long-term loyalty.

More Practical Tools for Students Powered by AI Study Helper

Homework AI Solver

Stylized AI Paper Writer

Plagiarism Checker Assistant

Citation AI Academic Writing Tool

In-Class Translation Assistant

AI Note Generator

AI Quiz Answers

Past Exam Questions from University Test Bank

Smart Practice Assistant

Adaptive Practice

Making Your Study Simpler