Questions
FA25_QTM_110_1 Quiz #5: Randomization and Inference
Multiple dropdown selections
Suppose we are interested in the effect of being a 1st round pick in the NBA draft (as opposed to a 2nd round pick or being undrafted) on minutes played in a person's NBA career. The theory is that 1st round picks are given more chances to show that they can be a successful player and are less likely to be cut than another player, all else equal. Those who are drafted in the first round are treated (T = 1) and all other NBA players are untreated (T = 0). You observe that there is a large positive difference in the average number of minutes played by first round picks and the average number of minutes played by other NBA players . You are worried, though, that skill as a basketball player confounds this relationship. You believe that a player's skill is positively correlated with receiving the treatment. Additionally, you believe that in a world where there is no NBA draft, highly skilled players are more likely to play more minutes than less skilled players. Given this information (and assuming that this is the only confounding variable that matters), the observed difference in averages overestimates the true effect of being a first round pick.
View Explanation
Verified Answer
Please login to view
Step-by-Step Analysis
The problem describes a causal inference scenario where being a first-round NBA draft pick (T = 1) is associated with more minutes played, but there is a potential confounder: player skill. Higher-skilled players are more likely to be drafted early and also tend to play more minutes, even in a world without the draft. This creates a positive confounding effect that inflates the observed difference in minutes between first-round picks and others.
First, outline the setup in your own words: We’re comparing minutes played between two groups......Login to view full explanationLog in for full answers
We've collected over 50,000 authentic exam questions and detailed explanations from around the globe. Log in now and get instant access to the answers!
Similar Questions
Imagine that in a large observational study comparing people who regularly take >=400 IU of vitamin D per day with people with no supplemental vitamin D intake, the crude incidence rate ratio of multiple sclerosis was 0.34. Smokers are less likely to take vitamin supplements and they are more likely to develop multiple sclerosis. If the authors of the observational study further adjust for smoking, the resulting adjusted incidence rate ratio may be
Suppose we are interested in the effect of being a 1st round pick in the NBA draft (as opposed to a 2nd round pick or being undrafted) on minutes played in a person's NBA career. The theory is that 1st round picks are given more chances to show that they can be a successful player and are less likely to be cut than another player, all else equal. Those who are drafted in the first round are treated (T = 1) and all other NBA players are untreated (T = 0). You observe that there is a large positive difference in the average number of minutes played by first round picks and the average number of minutes played by other NBA players . You are worried, though, that skill as a basketball player confounds this relationship. You believe that a player's skill is positively correlated with receiving the treatment. Additionally, you believe that in a world where there is no NBA draft, highly skilled players are more likely to play more minutes than less skilled players. Given this information (and assuming that this is the only confounding variable that matters), the observed difference in averages [选择] is unbiased for overestimates underestimates the true effect of being a first round pick.
In a consumer society, many adults channel creativity into buying things
Economic stress and unpredictable times have resulted in a booming industry for self-help products
More Practical Tools for Students Powered by AI Study Helper
Making Your Study Simpler
Join us and instantly unlock extensive past papers & exclusive solutions to get a head start on your studies!