If we were to discover that there is no Deuterium in a very distant, young cosmic cloud of gas, what problem would that create for cosmologists?

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

The question asks about the consequence for cosmologists if a distant, young cosmic cloud were found to lack Deuterium (D). The options present a range of possible implications that need evaluating based on standard cosmology and nucleosynthesis.

Option a: 'No problem at all!' This is incorrect because Deuterium is a key product of Big Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN). Its primordial abundance is a sensitive probe of early-universe conditions. Finding no D would challenge the predicted yields and the overall consistency of the standard cosmological model.

Option b: 'Galaxy formation models depend heavily on the presence of D, as it helps the clouds from which galaxies formed to coalesce.' While D plays a role in cooling processes in primordial gas through molecular deuterium (and related cooling pathways), the statement overstates the dependence of galaxy formation models on Deuterium to the extent implied. Many cooling channels and chemical pathways exist, and models would adapt rather than be invalidated solely by the absence of D. This option is not the strongest challenge presented by the scenario.

Option c: 'The Big Bang theory would be wrong, as it predicts the formation of D during the era of nucleosynthesis in the early Universe.' This is the core claim tying Deuterium to BBN: the standard model predicts a certain primordial D abundance produced during the first few minutes after the Big Bang. If no D were observed where it should be abundant, it would undermine the BBN predictions and thus challenge part of the Big Bang framework. This option directly links the absence of D to a fundamental conflict with BBN theory.

Option d: 'We would not have been here, as D is vital for life.' While Deuterium is a stable isotope and can be involved in some biochemical and astrophysical processes, life does not hinge on a single isotope being present in cosmic clouds. The absence of D would not categorically prevent life from arising elsewhere, making this claim scientifically overstated and incorrect as a universal necessity.

Option e: 'Fusion would never have started in the interiors of stars, since D is the first isotope to be participating in fusion reactions.' In stellar physics, hydrogen burning begins with protons fusing via the proton–proton chain or the CNO cycle, and while Deuterium is involved in some reaction chains, stars can and do fuse hydrogen without requiring pre-existing Deuterium as a starting fuel. This statement is inaccurate about stellar fusion processes and misstates the role of Deuterium in stellar interiors.

In summary, option c is the one that most directly captures the fundamental implication: a lack of Deuterium would challenge Big Bang nucleosynthesis predictions, thereby posing a problem for the standard cosmological narrative. The other choices either overstate certain dependencies, misstate how cosmological cooling or stellar fusion works, or incorrectly claim that such a discovery would have no impact. The reasoning emphasizes how Deuterium behaves as a key diagnostic for early-universe physics and the consistency of the Big Bang model with observed elemental abundances.

ASTR 350 ONL FA25: Big Bang,Black Holes,Universe (Liu, X)

If we were to discover that there is no Deuterium in a very distant, young cosmic cloud of gas, what problem would that create for cosmologists?

View Explanation

Log in for full answers

Similar Questions

You are in a hot, dense place. You are surrounded by protons and neutrons, some rapidly fusing into helium. You notice that your surroundings are cooling (good, because it's really hot!) and rapidly dropping in density. Within about 3 minutes, the fusion reactions stop. Where are you?

Most of the Hydrogen in the Universe was created in

Why were there only negligible amounts of elements heavier than Helium produced during the first three minutes after the Big Bang?

Why is the era of nucleosynthesis so important in determining the chemical composition of the universe?

What kinds of atomic nuclei formed during the Big Bang epoch of nucleosynthesis?

A few seconds/minutes after the Big Bang, what atoms formed?

Measuring the amount of deuterium in the universe allows us to set a limit on

In a consumer society, many adults channel creativity into buying things

More Practical Tools for Students Powered by AI Study Helper

Homework AI Solver

Stylized AI Paper Writer

Plagiarism Checker Assistant

Citation AI Academic Writing Tool

In-Class Translation Assistant

AI Note Generator

AI Quiz Answers

Past Exam Questions from University Test Bank

Smart Practice Assistant

Adaptive Practice

Making Your Study Simpler