Your colleague is delighted because in her lab today she successfully had E.coli take up a gene that produces a human protein, and the bacteria are now producing the human protein. She reports that this occurred this using DNA placed in the environment of the E.coli, and the bacteria took up the DNA without the use of a viral vector. She excitedly describes this as natural transformation. Is she correct?

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

The scenario involves a colleague reporting that E. coli in a lab took up a human gene and began producing human protein, allegedly through DNA exposure in the environment without a viral vector, and she calls this natural transformation.
Option 1: 'Yes, because E.coli is now capable a producing a new product this is natural transformation.' This is flawed because producing a new product alone does not define natural transformation, and the context specifies laboratory conditions and DNA uptake without a viral vector, which points away from natural transformation.
Option 2: 'Yes, because E.coli now has a new gene from another source in its chromosome this is natural transformation.' While acquiring a gene from another source is involved, the key issue is the method and setting. Natural transformation requires that the organism acquire DNA from its environment under natural conditions, not through lab manipulation, so calling it natural transformation here is inaccurate given the laboratory context and artificial method.
Option 3: 'No, because the newly incorporated gene is from a different species, this is artificial transformation.' The fact that the gene comes from a different species does not by itself define artificial transformation. Artificial transformation refers to lab-induced DNA uptake, but the species origin alone isn’t the criterion; the lab setting and method matter, and the claim hinges on artificial lab induction rather than a natural process.
Option 4: 'No, because this occurred in the laboratory, the process is transduction, not transformation.' Transduction requires a bacteriophage to transfer DNA, which is not indicated here. Since no viral vector is used and the DNA uptake is described as transformation-like without a vector, labeling it as transduction is incorrect.
Option 5: 'No, because this happened in the laboratory without the use of a viral vector this is artificial transformation.' This option correctly identifies two crucial points: (a) the lab setting means the process is not naturally occurring in nature, and (b) the absence of a viral vector indicates the mechanism is not transduction. The appropriate term for lab-induced uptake of naked DNA by bacteria is artificial transformation, not a natural process, so the statement aligns with standard microbiology terminology.
In sum, the scenario is best described as artificial transformation because it involves deliberate laboratory conditions enabling uptake of naked DNA without a viral vector, rather than a natural transformation occurring in nature or a phage-mediated transduction process.

View Explanation

Log in for full answers

Similar Questions

Bacterial transformation is a highly efficient process

If an experiment is set up to show transformation in bacteria, what must be present in the environment for it to be successful?

Bacterial transformation occurs when

When a bacterium takes up DNA from the extracellular environment it is known as:

Below are illustrated five plates prepared using the same protocol used in the pGLO experiment. (Note that the plate numbers here do not correspond to the plate numbers in your lab manual tables.) In which plate do we expect to see no bacterial colonies?

Below are illustrated five plates prepared using the same protocol used in the pGLO experiment. (Note that the plate numbers here do not correspond to the plate numbers in your lab manual tables.) In which plate do we expect to see many bacterial colonies, but no fluorescent colonies?

More Practical Tools for Students Powered by AI Study Helper

Homework AI Solver

Stylized AI Paper Writer

Plagiarism Checker Assistant

Citation AI Academic Writing Tool

In-Class Translation Assistant

AI Note Generator

AI Quiz Answers

Past Exam Questions from University Test Bank

Smart Practice Assistant

Adaptive Practice

Making Your Study Simpler