Using Dalton's Atomic theory, explain the following observation.
Hint: DO NOT answer with a law!
The mass of the products at the end of the reaction was the same as the mass of the reactants at the beginning.

Question

Using Dalton's Atomic theory, explain the following observation.  
Hint:  DO NOT answer with a law!
The mass of the products at the end of the reaction was the same as the mass of the reactants at the beginning.

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

The prompt asks us to use Dalton's Atomic Theory to explain the observation that the mass of the products at the end of the reaction is the same as the mass of the reactants at the beginning, and it cautions not to answer with a law. The question explicitly requests a Daltonian explanation of mass conservation in a chemical reaction.

First, note that Dalton’s Atomic Theory posits that matter is composed of indivisible atoms, that atoms are neither created nor destroyed in chemical reactions, and that reactions involve only the rearrangement of existing atoms to form new substances. Applying this to the observation, you can reason as follows:
- Atoms are conserved: the total number and type of atoms before and after the reaction remain the same because atoms are not created or annihilated.
- Rearrangement leads to new substances: the atoms present in the reactants are reorganized into the products with different chemical bonds and compositions, but without any loss or gain of mass.
- Mass equivalence follows from atom conservation: since the same atoms are present before and after, and there are no changes in the intrinsic masses of the atoms themselves, the total mass must be the same.

Potential misconceptions to avoid:
- Thinking mass changes because substances look different. The difference in appearance or properties does not imply a gain or loss of mass; it reflects changes in how atoms are bonded and arranged.
- Attributing mass change to the activity of the law of conservation of mass alone. While the law of conservation of mass is a guiding principle, your explanation should explicitly connect it to Dalton’s idea that atoms are conserved and merely rearranged, rather than invoking the law as the explanation itself.
- Assuming atoms are indivisible in all contexts. In modern chemistry we know atoms can be subdivided (into protons, neutrons, electrons, and subatomic particles), but Dalton’s theory uses the concept of atoms as the smallest unit of matter for chemical reactions, which is sufficient for explaining mass conservation in this historical framing.

In summary, the observation is explained by Dalton’s core assertion that atoms are neither created nor destroyed in chemical reactions; the reactants’ atoms are simply rearranged to form products, so the total mass remains unchanged. If you had multiple answer choices, you would look for the option that emphasizes atom conservation and rearrangement as the mechanism for mass conservation, rather than a statement that invokes a separate law or suggests mass can disappear or appear during the reaction.

Using Dalton's Atomic theory, explain the following observation. Hint: DO NOT answer with a law! The mass of the products at the end of the reaction was the same as the mass of the reactants at the beginning.

View Explanation

Log in for full answers

Similar Questions

Using Dalton's Atomic theory, explain the following observation. Hint: DO NOT answer with a law! Water is always found the ratio of 8 g of oxygen to 1 g of hydrogen, whereas hydrogen peroxide is always found in the ratio of 16 g of oxygen to 1 g of hydrogen.

Which of the following laws is not directly related to the concept of atoms?

Which part(s) of Dalton's atomic theory have been proven to be incorrect?

Identify the bond angle and molecular shape of H2O.

The number of valence electrons in a sulfur atom is 16.

If matter is uniform throughout and can be separated into multiple substances by physical means, it is called a(n) ________________.

Circle the letter for all examples of chemical change. Circle all correct answers.

Which of the following Lewis structures are incorrect? There may be more than one.

More Practical Tools for International Students

Exam Browser Assistant

Stylized Writing Assistant

Plagiarism Checker Assistant

Citation Assistant

In-Class Translation Assistant

Class Notes Assistant

Quiz Search Assistant

Past Exam Questions by School

Smart Practice Assistant

Adaptive Practice

Making Your Study Simpler