Is Sonja violating academic integrity standards by using content from another assignment?

Question

BlackTom AI · Accepted Answer

The question asks whether Sonja is violating academic integrity standards by using content from another assignment. We will assess each option for accuracy and alignment with common academic integrity policies.
Option 1: 'No. The paper wasn’t exactly the same. Sonja updated its data and argument.' While superficially different, reusing substantial portions of one’s own prior work (self-plagiarism) can still violate policy, especially if prior work has not been properly authorized or cited. The description of updating data and argument does not automatically make the action permissible. This answer risks underestimating the requirement for permission or proper citation.
Option 2: 'Yes. Sonja can’t resubmit her own work without authorization from the instructor.' This reflects a standard academic integrity rule: submitting work that has been previously submitted for another course or assignment without explicit permission is typically considered self-plagiarism and a violation. Even if the work originated with Sonja, institutions often require instructor approval to reuse prior submissions, making this a strong justification for why it would be a violation.
Option 3: 'No. Sonja did not intend to cheat. That is why she changed some of the material.' The intention to cheat is not the sole determinant of an integrity violation. Many policies consider the act of reusing substantial prior work, regardless of intent, as a violation if proper authorization or citation is lacking. Merely changing some material does not automatically absolve the action.
Option 4: 'No. Sonja wrote the original paper herself.' Even if she authored the original work, re-submitting the same or substantially similar content without authorization can still constitute self-plagiarism or academic dishonesty depending on policy. The fact that she wrote it previously does not guarantee permission to reuse it where it’s not allowed.
In evaluating these options, focus on the core policy concept: resubmission or reuse of one’s own prior work without proper authorization or citation is typically considered an academic integrity violation, whereas merely claiming originality or intent does not override policy requirements.

AITUT_AY2526_TUT4 Scenario | Sonja's Recycle

Is Sonja violating academic integrity standards by using content from another assignment?

View Explanation

Log in for full answers

Similar Questions

I can submit work from a different class to fulfill course requirements without engaging in academic misconduct.

Allowing others to complete paper assignments, whether it is paid or not, counts as cheating.

I agree to abide by Pacific's Honor Code before beginning this exam.

Cheating on the placement assessment could result in enrollment into a course that is too difficult, or not challenging enough, potentially costing time and money.

Cheating on the placement assessment could result in enrollment into a course that is too difficult, or not challenging enough, potentially costing time and money.

Repeated instances of plagiarism can result in failure in the course and expulsion from the college.

I acknowledge and agree to uphold the BYU CE Academic Integrity Policy and all exam rules and proctoring guidelines.

More Practical Tools for Students Powered by AI Study Helper

Homework AI Solver

Stylized AI Paper Writer

Plagiarism Checker Assistant

Citation AI Academic Writing Tool

In-Class Translation Assistant

AI Note Generator

AI Quiz Answers

Past Exam Questions from University Test Bank

Smart Practice Assistant

Adaptive Practice

Making Your Study Simpler